![]() |
|
|
My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Andrew Sullivan Tim Blair* James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Punditwatch (Will Vehrs)* Kausfiles Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Samizdata Michael Barone Space/Science
Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Charles Murtaugh* Lagniappe (Derek Lowe)* Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression* Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold)* Mars Blog Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington)* Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin)* Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Econoblog* Live from the WTC (Megan McArdle) More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil)* Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Andragna & Vehrs)* Joanne Jacobs England's Sword (Iain Murray)* Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit* Daimnation! (Damian Penny)* Aspara Girl Flit Unremitting Verse (Will Warren)* World View (Brink Lindsay) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal* Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Random Jottings (John Weidner)* Natalie Solent* On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One* A libertarian reads the papers* Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review* Ben Kepple's Daily Rant* Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files* Dawson.com* Dodgeblog* Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher)* End the War on Freedom* Fevered Rants* Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas* Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan* James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar* Mind over what matters* Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt* Photodude Privacy Digest Quare* Rantburg Recovering Liberal* Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War* The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey* Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet* Ye Olde Blogge (Andrea Harris) Zem : blog
Powered by Movable Type |
Mickey Misses The Point Glenn and Mickey Kaus (see the Cinco de Mayo i.e., May 5 entry), as a result of others' blogging about it have started discussing the journalism scandal at the Gray Lady, in which a reporter was fired for plagiarism. It was since discovered that he had been corrected what seemed an inordinate number of times, and retained his job until the most recent egregious violation of journalistic ethics. Not unnaturally, because he was black, it has caused many to speculate that his seemingly too-lengthy tenure, and perhaps even his initial hiring, given his record, was due to affirmative action. Others (like Glenn) point out that his record isn't necessarily worse than many white reporters, so it isn't clear that this is the case. Here's where Mickey goes off the rails. He uses an analogy to make his point, and it turns out to be an excellent one--so much so that it makes his opponents' point. Suppose in an effort to promote commerce in isolated Utah, the government announced relaxed safety standards on trucks from that state. Utah trucks were safe, the public was told. Many were even safer than trucks from other states. But they wouldn't be inspected as often or as rigorously. His point would be valid if the people saying that it wasn't necessarily the hand of affirmative action at work were also saying that therefore we should keep affirmative action (or that the fact that we can't obviously blame non-inspection for the truck accident as a justification for non-uniform laws). Now, I haven't read anything to indicate that's the case (though I imagine it will be coming soon if it hasn't already), but it does nothing to rebut Glenn's point, which is simply that the evidence doesn't necessarily show that affirmative action (or lax trucking inspections) was responsible. I suspect that Glenn would (as would I) say that it's possible to both not be convinced that this particular incident was a result of the bad policies, and still support changing the policies. I think that there's ample evidence, and theory, to justify ending affirmative action in particular, without the need to resort to this particular incident to support that course. Surely Mickey (and others) don't fantasize that this will somehow be the straw that snaps the camel's spine? [Should we also ask why Mickey would pick on the state of Utah? Could it be because of all the white folks there?--ed. No, let's not go there.] That is, I oppose affirmative action (and differential trucking inspection regimes, since, unlike most federal legislation falsely justified by that flawed portion of the Constitution, those clearly fall under the Commerce Clause), and believe that it indeed should be ended for the reasons that Mickey states, and others, but like Glenn, I remain unconvinced that this particular instance was a result of that policy (though I certainly remain convinceable, given sufficient evidence and insufficient counterevidence). However, I also have no trouble, given the state to which the NYT has declined recently, believing that it can also simply be attributed to lousy management and/or agendas. I do hope that this latest episode results in either continued loss of credibility to a paper that is having an increasingly corrosive effect on public discourse, or a change in editorial and managerial direction that might restore it to its former lofty place in American journalism. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 05, 2003 06:48 AM
Comments
> I oppose affirmative action Do you think that the government should do anything to try to address the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow? If not, why? And if so, what? I think that the federal government has done more than enough to do that, and in fact, has done so much as to further harm the original victims of those institutions, by generating a culture of dependency. This brouhaha, in which it is assumed by many that the reporter got and kept his job for so long largely because of his race, whether true or not, is a one perfect example of the damage done by such policies. At this point, the best way to address racial injustices of the past is to abolish the bizarre notion of race from the federal code, particularly since it doesn't even have a scientific basis. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 5, 2003 12:12 PMPost a comment |