![]() |
|
|
My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Andrew Sullivan Tim Blair* James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Punditwatch (Will Vehrs)* Kausfiles Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Samizdata Michael Barone Space/Science
Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Charles Murtaugh* Lagniappe (Derek Lowe)* Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression* Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold)* Mars Blog Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington)* Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin)* Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Econoblog* Live from the WTC (Megan McArdle) More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil)* Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Andragna & Vehrs)* Joanne Jacobs England's Sword (Iain Murray)* Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit* Daimnation! (Damian Penny)* Aspara Girl Flit Unremitting Verse (Will Warren)* World View (Brink Lindsay) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal* Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Random Jottings (John Weidner)* Natalie Solent* On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One* A libertarian reads the papers* Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review* Ben Kepple's Daily Rant* Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files* Dawson.com* Dodgeblog* Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher)* End the War on Freedom* Fevered Rants* Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas* Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan* James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar* Mind over what matters* Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt* Photodude Privacy Digest Quare* Rantburg Recovering Liberal* Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War* The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey* Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet* Ye Olde Blogge (Andrea Harris) Zem : blog
Powered by Movable Type |
A Verbal Blow For Freedom Most aren't going to want to download and read the entire ruling and dissents from this week's 9th Circuit declaration that the right to bear arms isn't an individual one, but it's a very important one. It's in direct conflict with the 5th Circuit's decision in Emerson, which means that it will almost certainly go to the Supreme Court, which will finally resolve this issue, and hopefully restore the Second Amendment to its rightful place in the Bill of Rights, and make a legal hash of much of the existing federal gun statutes. Along that theme, it's worth republishing here Judge Kozinski's eloquent dissent, which is a commentary not only on the issue at hand, but in some judges being "cafeteria constitutionalists," broadly stretching some aspects of the Constitution far beyond any intent of the Founders, while completely ignoring others, according to their personal political predilections. Judges know very well how to read the Constitution broadly when they are sympathetic to the right being asserted. We have held, without much ado, that "speech, or . . . the press" also means the Internet, see Reno v. ACLU, 521 U.S. 844 (1997), and that "persons, houses, papers, and effects" also means public telephone booths, see Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967). When a particular right comports especially well with our notions of good social policy, we build magnificent legal edifices on elliptical constitutional phrases—or even the white spaces between lines of constitutional text. See, e.g., Compassion in Dying v. Washington, 79 F.3d 790 (9th Cir. 1996) (en banc), rev’d sub nom. Washington v. Glucksberg, 521 U.S. 702 (1997). But, as the panel amply demonstrates, when we’re none too keen on a particular constitutional guarantee, we can be equally ingenious in burying language that is incontrovertibly there. [Update on Wednesday morning] Eugene Volokh has some thoughts on whether or not the case will make it to the Supreme Court. Bottom line: he doesn't know--there are too many unknown factors that will drive the decision. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 06, 2003 08:36 PM
Comments
Eloquent and excellent. I just hope that he would apply the same level of defense to the 9th and 10th amendments. Posted by Hermetic at May 7, 2003 06:05 AMI keep thinking (with a chuckle) about Justice Thomas's response to a question about what he thought of Al Gore's description of the Constitution as a "living breathing document": "My copy appears to be inanimate." Posted by Joshua Chamberlain at May 7, 2003 07:06 AM> "My copy appears to be inanimate." I'm not sure that that is necessarily a good thing in a constitution. Posted by Dave at May 7, 2003 07:09 AMIt's an excellent thing in a Constitution, as long as there are provisions for explicitly changing it, which there are. Otherwise it becomes meaningless, and subject to the whims of individual and mercurial judges (which is in fact what has happened to a large degree over the past few decades). Posted by Rand Simberg at May 7, 2003 07:36 AMOh My God!! A reasoned, thought out, historically accurate defense of the Second Ammendment. I hope we get this level of support WHEN it gets to the Supreme Court. If not, I propose we join the rattlesnake and bite the Sumo on the arse, repeatedly. Posted by Steve at May 7, 2003 08:00 AM> as long as there are provisions for explicitly changing it, which there are. It depends on what those provisions are. If, for example, they are crafted to make changes difficult, perhaps too difficult, you can end up with an arcane document which has little or no bearing in certain areas. NB: I'm not neccesarily talking about the US one, just constitutions in general. Posted by Dave at May 7, 2003 09:19 AMPost a comment |