![]() |
|
|
My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Andrew Sullivan Tim Blair* James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Punditwatch (Will Vehrs)* Kausfiles Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Samizdata Michael Barone Space/Science
Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Charles Murtaugh* Lagniappe (Derek Lowe)* Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression* Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold)* Mars Blog Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington)* Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin)* Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Econoblog* Live from the WTC (Megan McArdle) More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil)* Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Andragna & Vehrs)* Joanne Jacobs England's Sword (Iain Murray)* Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit* Daimnation! (Damian Penny)* Aspara Girl Flit Unremitting Verse (Will Warren)* World View (Brink Lindsay) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal* Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Random Jottings (John Weidner)* Natalie Solent* On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One* A libertarian reads the papers* Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review* Ben Kepple's Daily Rant* Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files* Dawson.com* Dodgeblog* Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher)* End the War on Freedom* Fevered Rants* Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas* Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan* James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar* Mind over what matters* Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt* Photodude Privacy Digest Quare* Rantburg Recovering Liberal* Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War* The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey* Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet* Ye Olde Blogge (Andrea Harris) Zem : blog
Powered by Movable Type |
Having Trouble With The Concept I was going to note something about the story (available from several sources) that Rep. Joe Barton wants to shut down the Shuttle program because it might kill astronauts. Either that, or fly it unmanned, which is an utterly senseless idea. The significance of this is that the congressman is from Texas, tribal homeland of the Shuttle, and he's on the Space and Aeronautics subcommittee. I'm not necessarily opposed to ending the current manned spaceflight program in its present form--there are several arguably good reasons to do so even if one supports humans in space, but to do it because it's unsafe is, well, stupid. It would be yet another case of doing (possibly) the right thing for completely the wrong reason, and when we do right things for wrong reasons, it dramatically diminishes the possibility of doing follow-up right things. Anyway, fortunately, I don't have to say much, because Thomas James already has. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 10, 2003 08:31 AM
Comments
It would do us a world of good to just develop Soyuz-like capsules that can be used on ELVs until a much cheaper and useful design for an RLV can replace it. I used to defend the shuttle but I'm beginning to agree with much of the crowd that's it a tragedy that we ever developed it. Sometimes it's good to just stop doing things the old way and take some time off to build a better mouse trap. I get the feeling that scrapping the shuttle is the only way we can achieve more economical space access, otherwise NASA might just keep fighting to keep its welfare machine alive. Posted by X at May 10, 2003 04:23 PMThank God that these people were not in charge in Europe in the 15th and 16th centuries. We would all be living in ??(enter GG-Grandparents country of origin here) After all someone might have died crossing the ocean to get here. Posted by Steve at May 11, 2003 08:02 AMWell, one way to say it is that it's too unsafe given the amount that's spent keeping it alive and the meager benefits it provides. Improve those other things and the tolerance for danger might increase-- risk is more understandable in the name of something worth doing. The Planetary Society's member directory allowed each member to suggest an image that they believed should be sent across space to some alien intelligence. People suggested the old gold Voyager plaque and DNA, but the shuttle was one of the most common responses. The shuttle was the very symbol of what we accomplished as a race. With its life science package it was in essence a very adaptable space station. It's ability to carry up to seven astronauts for two weeks in relative comfort was well beyond any Gemini-Soyuz capsule and it really did bring back a lot for reuse: including the service module for its crew, the airlock, and docking ring. It established a benchmark, generated a lot of public interest, and proved that long EVA’s were indeed very possible. Even before the accident there were signs that NASA just couldn’t support it. Cracks were found, wires frayed…. The list of problems just kept growing while the workload skyrocketed. I’m sure the remaining vehicles themselves could enjoy a substantial future carrier, but can NASA keep critical mission people up-to-snuff for the next year until the next launch. With fewer launches – will support people forget to do critical things? Would another failure right off the bat end our Space Program all together? I like the shuttle, but I am in favor of dropping the anchor here – unfortunately I don’t believe NASA or the Gov. would know what to do next. Wondering Why the shuttle is old and Failing? The gross difference between the NASA budgit and the military budgit (20 times greater) is aptly demonstrated by the number of weapon systems deployed since NASA's current STS Colombia-Class Space Shuttle landed the drawing boards in late 1973. Since then, the military has deployed: the E-3 AWACS, the J-Stars AWACS, the F-15A-E, the F-16, the F-18A-D, F-18E/F, the F-22, the A-10, the S-3, the AH-64 and AH-66, the UH-60, the C-17, the KC-10, the AV-8B Harrior, the T-45, the B-1B the B-2, the V-22, and has deployed twice as many Nimitz Class Nuclear Aircraft Carriers than space shuttles! Since the begining of Shuttle’s development, the US has developed and developed five (5) long range, hydrogen-bomb-tipped nuclear missiels: (Trident I: 8 100kt MIRVs - 384 deployed - Total=307,200kt.) who's total warhead yield is 2,234,550kt: or 97,154 times greater than the Fat Man Atomic Weapon droped on Nagasaki in 1945. All this....all this, and we have the nerve to talk about "Weapons of Mass Distruction?" Rand, I'm sorry, but you are wrong to condemn the idea of flying the Shuttle with no people aboard. This is an excellent idea, which was in the hopper before the Columbia tragedy. Why is flying the Shuttle umanned a good idea? (a) Because the Shuttle is needed for some heavy cargo launches of new space telescopes and similar large payloads during the next few years. ... Non-ISS paylaods, by the way. (b) Because flying the Shuttle unmanned is quite feasible. (c) Because doing so is an exvcellent end-of-life plan for the three remaining Shuttles. There's less to worry about if the trip is only one way, OK? ... As for an American Soyuz-type thang: that gets my vote only if it's done to cut the Russians out of the ISS business because of their duplicity in Iraq and Iran. This may not be a bad idea. In terms of cost effectivness, though, it's quicker and cheaper to pay the Rooskies for additional Soyuz launches, instead of developing an American capsule. Why duplicate the Soyuz, except for the aforementioned geopolitical reason? -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by David Davenport at May 14, 2003 10:36 AMRand, I'm sorry, but you are wrong to condemn the idea of flying the Shuttle with no people aboard. This is an excellent idea, which was in the hopper before the Columbia tragedy. Why is flying the Shuttle umanned a good idea? (a) Because the Shuttle is needed for some heavy cargo launches of new space telescopes and similar large payloads during the next few years. ... Non-ISS paylaods, by the way. (b) Because flying the Shuttle unmanned is quite feasible. (c) Because doing so is an exvcellent end-of-life plan for the three remaining Shuttles. There's less to worry about if the trip is only one way, OK? ... As for an American Soyuz-type thang: that gets my vote only if it's done to cut the Russians out of the ISS business because of their duplicity in Iraq and Iran. This may not be a bad idea. In terms of cost effectivness, though, it's quicker and cheaper to pay the Rooskies for additional Soyuz launches, instead of developing an American capsule. Why duplicate the Soyuz, except for the aforementioned geopolitical reason? -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by David Davenport at May 14, 2003 10:36 AMRand, I'm sorry, but you are wrong to condemn the idea of flying the Shuttle with no people aboard. This is an excellent idea, which was in the hopper before the Columbia tragedy. Why is flying the Shuttle umanned a good idea? (a) Because the Shuttle is needed for some heavy cargo launches of new space telescopes and similar large payloads during the next few years. ... Non-ISS paylaods, by the way. (b) Because flying the Shuttle unmanned is quite feasible. (c) Because doing so is an exvcellent end-of-life plan for the three remaining Shuttles. There's less to worry about if the trip is only one way, OK? ... As for an American Soyuz-type thang: that gets my vote only if it's done to cut the Russians out of the ISS business because of their duplicity in Iraq and Iran. This may not be a bad idea. In terms of cost effectivness, though, it's quicker and cheaper to pay the Rooskies for additional Soyuz launches, instead of developing an American capsule. Why duplicate the Soyuz, except for the aforementioned geopolitical reason? -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by David Davenport at May 14, 2003 10:36 AMRand, I'm sorry, but you are wrong to condemn the idea of flying the Shuttle with no people aboard. This is an excellent idea, which was in the hopper before the Columbia tragedy. Why is flying the Shuttle umanned a good idea? (a) Because the Shuttle is needed for some heavy cargo launches of new space telescopes and similar large payloads during the next few years. ... Non-ISS paylaods, by the way. (b) Because flying the Shuttle unmanned is quite feasible. (c) Because doing so is an exvcellent end-of-life plan for the three remaining Shuttles. There's less to worry about if the trip is only one way, OK? ... As for an American Soyuz-type thang: that gets my vote only if it's done to cut the Russians out of the ISS business because of their duplicity in Iraq and Iran. This may not be a bad idea. In terms of cost effectivness, though, it's quicker and cheaper to pay the Rooskies for additional Soyuz launches, instead of developing an American capsule. Why duplicate the Soyuz, except for the aforementioned geopolitical reason? -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by David Davenport at May 14, 2003 10:36 AMRand, I'm sorry, but you are wrong to condemn the idea of flying the Shuttle with no people aboard. This is an excellent idea, which was in the hopper before the Columbia tragedy. Why is flying the Shuttle umanned a good idea? (a) Because the Shuttle is needed for some heavy cargo launches of new space telescopes and similar large payloads during the next few years. ... Non-ISS paylaods, by the way. (b) Because flying the Shuttle unmanned is quite feasible. (c) Because doing so is an exvcellent end-of-life plan for the three remaining Shuttles. There's less to worry about if the trip is only one way, OK? ... As for an American Soyuz-type thang: that gets my vote only if it's done to cut the Russians out of the ISS business because of their duplicity in Iraq and Iran. This may not be a bad idea. In terms of cost effectivness, though, it's quicker and cheaper to pay the Rooskies for additional Soyuz launches, instead of developing an American capsule. Why duplicate the Soyuz, except for the aforementioned geopolitical reason? -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by David Davenport at May 14, 2003 10:37 AM[ Wondering Why the shuttle is old and Failing? The gross difference between the NASA budgit and the military budgit (20 times greater) is aptly demonstrated by the number of weapon systems ...] Noipe, Mr. Left Lib. NASA had $980 M-plus to develop the X-33 during the Clinton years, and NASA blew it. Lack of money is not NASA's problem. If a new OSP is to be developed, the DoD will probably have to do it. -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by at May 14, 2003 10:38 AM[ Wondering Why the shuttle is old and Failing? The gross difference between the NASA budgit and the military budgit (20 times greater) is aptly demonstrated by the number of weapon systems ...] Noipe, Mr. Left Lib. NASA had $980 M-plus to develop the X-33 during the Clinton years, and NASA blew it. Lack of money is not NASA's problem. If a new OSP is to be developed, the DoD will probably have to do it. -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by at May 14, 2003 10:38 AM[ Wondering Why the shuttle is old and Failing? The gross difference between the NASA budgit and the military budgit (20 times greater) is aptly demonstrated by the number of weapon systems ...] Noipe, Mr. Left Lib. NASA had $980 M-plus to develop the X-33 during the Clinton years, and NASA blew it. Lack of money is not NASA's problem. If a new OSP is to be developed, the DoD will probably have to do it. -- david.davenport@mindspring.com Posted by at May 14, 2003 10:39 AMPost a comment |