![]() |
|
![]() Support democracy and human rights in Iraq! ![]() Reader's Favorites
Media Casualties Mount Administration Split On Europe Invasion Administration In Crisis Over Burgeoning Quagmire Congress Concerned About Diversion From War On Japan Pot, Kettle On Line Two... Allies Seize Paris The Natural Gore Book Sales Tank, Supporters Claim Unfair Tactics Satan Files Lack Of Defamation Suit Why This Blog Bores People With Space Stuff A New Beginning My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Andrew Sullivan Tim Blair James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Kausfiles Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Samizdata Eject Eject Eject (Bill Whittle) Space/Science
Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Charles Murtaugh* Lagniappe (Derek Lowe) Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression Carl Zimmer Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) Space Today (Jeff Foust) RLV News (Clark Lindsey) A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold)* Mars Blog Laughing Wolf (C. Blake Powers) Rocketman (Mark Oakley) Rocket Forge (Michael Mealing) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington)* Pathetic Earthlings (Andrew Lloyd) The Speculist (Phil Bowermaster) Spacecraft (Chris Hall) Nanobot (Howard Lovy)* Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin)* Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Assymetrical Information (Jane Galt and Mindles H. Dreck) Marginal Revolution (Tyler Cowen et al) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil)* Knowledge Problem (Lynne Kiesling) More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) The Funny Pages
Cox & Forkum Day By Day Happy Fun Pundit The Onion Amish Tech Support (Lawrence Simon) Scrapple Face (Scott Ott) Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Adragna & Vehrs)* Joanne Jacobs England's Sword (Iain Murray) Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit* Daimnation! (Damian Penny)* Aspara Girl Flit Unremitting Verse (Will Warren)* World View (Brink Lindsay) Z+ Blog (Andrew Zolli) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal* Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Dean's World (Dean Esmay) Blogosferics (Kevin McGeheel) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Spleenville (Andrea Harris) Random Jottings (John Weidner) Natalie Solent* On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One* A libertarian reads the papers* Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review* Ben Kepple's Daily Rant* Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files* Dawson.com* Dodgeblog Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher)* End the War on Freedom* Fevered Rants* Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas* Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan* James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar* Mind over what matters* Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt* Photodude Privacy Digest Quare* Rantburg Recovering Liberal* Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War* The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey* Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet* Zem : blog Space Policy Links
Space Future The Space Review Nasa Watch Hobby Space Space Frontier Foundation Space Policy Digest BBS
Powered by Movable Type |
About Infinity...And Beyond!
March 05, 2004
Extropian On The Lam I used to be fairly close to Keith Henson (who is, among other things, co-founder of the L-5 Society), back in the late seventies and early eighties, but I haven't heard from him since he took refuge in Canada, a few years ago, from an adverse court judgement in his little war with the Scientologists. So I found this interview with him [via Clark Lindsey] quite interesting. You may as well. Posted by Rand Simberg at04:20 PM | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)
Not Your Father's Space Program
Clark Lindsey points out that the SpaceX Falcon is making steady progress toward first flight. Among all the other milestones noted, I found this one little bit extremely significant: Regulators gave them "approval to fly the rocket with only thrust cutoff, rather than explosive termination."... "[This] improves hazardous procedures in transportation, on the launch pad and particularly on recovery of the first stage." This [was] allowed "due to the all liquid fuel configuration and six-fold valve redundancy." As far as I'm aware, the only previous launch system that received permission to fly without range-safety destruct was the SET-1 launch by the American Rocket Company in 1989. The general philosophy has always been that range safety must be able to not only terminate thrust, but destroy the vehicle, should it go out of control. Rockets have always had such range safety devices, and are unique among all other transportation systems in that regard. No ship, train or plane has had devices on board every trip whose sole purpose is to destroy the vehicle. If SpaceX has gotten permission to launch without it, with only thrust termination, this may be a first for a liquid-fueled rocket (the American Rocket vehicle was a hybrid, with solid fuel and LOX). The big advantage, as it points out, is that there are now no pyrotechnic (explosive) devices on the vehicle, at least not for that purpose, which eliminates some of the steps in launch processing, and post-launch safing, and reduces one of the hazards associated with ground handling (not to mention greatly enhancing the probability of getting the first stage back, even in the event of a mission failure). Getting such permission is obviously much more important for a reusable vehicle, which the Falcon first stage is advertised to be. They don't want to have to destroy the vehicle just because it isn't following the prescribed trajectory, if they continue to have control over it, because they want to get it back. This is a key breakthrough in reducing launch costs. Let's hope that it presages the future. Posted by Rand Simberg at02:58 PM | Comments (7) | TrackBack (0)
Empire in the Sky
Via Mark Whittington, a piece in the Washington Times on a new age of exploration. The author, Jeremi Suri, asserts that the Bush space policy could be the start of a new age of exploration similar to that of the 17th and 18th centuries. This is certainly the hope of the vast majority of readers of this blog. The devil, as always, is in the details. The age of exploration had a lot to do with the efforts of Prince Henry the Navigator, who more or less kickstarted the whole thing. Take a look at the timeline from Henry's early efforts (1420 onwards) until the beginning of real profitable trade (mid 1450s). The real overseas european empires didn't really take root for another century. Had Henry and his compatriots thrown all their energies into building an empire spanning the globe, they'd never have had the resources to do the little things that lead to the big things. As it is, they had some adventures, made a name for themselves, and some of them got quite rich. Along the way they laid the groundwork for the empires to come. We are currently at the Henry the Navigator stage, and we should not lose sight of that fact. The next steps are small and modest, but necessary if we are to move on to bigger and better things. Bush was right to put the emphasis on return to the moon first, despite the fact that most commentators can't seem to get their minds off Mars. Mars will still be there in 30 years, or however long it takes. In the meantime we have the moon right there, staring us in the face. Near Earth Asteroids are being discovered so fast that it no longer makes news unless they are headed for a near collision with earth. Our Azores and our Guinea are waiting within reach. Also worth checking out is the wikipedia page on Henry. Posted by Andrew Case at11:04 AM | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)
Victims' Relatives Upset By Presidential Campaign Ad
July 8, 1944 WASHINGTON DC (Routers) Several relatives of those lost in the tragic attack on Pearl Harbor, two and a half years ago, have expressed shock and outrage over use of attack footage in a presidential campaign newsreel. Recently released to movie theatres in the wake of the recent nomination of New York Governor Thomas Dewey to run against President Roosevelt this fall, the ads were clearly intended to have a "morning in America" theme, playing up the Roosevelt administration's accomplishments. These include ongoing success in the "war on Nazi terror" and against Shinto extremism. The newsreels seemed designed to capitalize on the recent Normandy invasion, which has provided an allied foothold in France, and in the recent air/naval victory in the Phillippine Sea, which allowed the US to break the Japanese inner defenses with the capture of the Marianas. The administration believes that these events, along with the news that the Japanese are starting to retreat from Burma, provide an opportunity to frame a positive message before the Dewey campaign has time to define itself. But not all view the newsreels positively. "I lost a son on the Arizona," said Lucille Whinehardt, in town from Sioux Falls to protest. "I was sitting in the theatre, waiting to see 'The Song of Bernadette,' when the campaign reel came on, and I had to relive his loss." "I go to the movies to escape, not to watch his ship sinking and burning over and over again." "It's absolutely inappropriate," said Marian Davis, who lost her brother, Ned Flewelling, and leads Never Again, a group for victims' families. "There are certain memories and certain images that I consider sacred." Doris Kelly, of Bakersfield, CA, whose husband, John, died in the attack, said Roosevelt should not use the tragedy as "political propaganda." "Hundreds of innocent soldiers were murdered on President Roosevelt's watch," she said. Media critics agree that the newsreel campaign is very insensitive to the feelings of the victims. In addition, the US Chamber of Commerce, which has endorsed Mr. Dewey, has passed a resolution demanding that the Roosevelt administration pull the newsreels immediately. The Roosevelt campaign is defending the ads, however. "December 7th changed the equation in our public policy. It forever changed the world," said the White House press secretary. "The president's steady leadership is vital to how we wage war on Japan and Germany." Some of the victims' families agree. "These images honor those whose lives were lost," said Mildred Farnsworth, whose brother, James, died on the battleship Oklahoma. Proudly wearing her "Remember Pearl Harbor" button, she continued, "I guess some people just don't want to be reminded that we are at war." Copyright 2004 by Rand Simberg Posted by Rand Simberg at10:06 AM | Comments (26) | TrackBack (3)
March 04, 2004
SubOrbital Day It's fitting that my first post on Transterrestrial Musings is on suborbital industry lobbying - it certainly won't be my last on this topic. The Suborbital Institute has announced that it will be holding an event on May 17-18 to lobby congress on issues affecting the nascent suborbital spaceflight industry. If you are in the DC area or are able to travel to the area please join us. I'll be there, as will various folks from the alt.space crowd. The date is chosen so that people planning to attend the May COMSTAC meeting can just come a couple of days early. I've been involved with the SubOrbital Institute since the beginning, and it's a good bunch of people. SubOrbital days are interesting and fun, though there's no doubt that it's real work. I'll post more on the institute and its agenda in the coming weeks. On the topic of suborbital spaceflight, X-Rocket has revamped their website and they have some very interesting news. They have a working operational demonstrator for their planned vehicle, and they have test flights. Congratulations to X-Rocket and Ed Wright (who is one of the founders of the SubOrbital Institute). Link via HobbySpace.
03:31 PM | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)
Good News
Sometimes Congress isn't totally clueless. The new launch legislation passed today. It certainly sounds like Chairman Boehlert gets it: "This is about a lot more than 'joy rides' in space, although there's nothing wrong with such an enterprise. This is about the future of the U.S. aerospace industry. As in most areas of American enterprise, the greatest innovations in aerospace are most likely to come from small entrepreneurs. This is true whether we're talking about launching humans or cargo. And the goal of this bill is to promote robust experimentation, to make sure that entrepreneurs and inventors have the incentives and the capabilities they need to pursue their ideas. That's important to our nation's future." Now on to the Senate. I hope they don't screw it up too much. Posted by Rand Simberg at12:23 PM | Comments (12) | TrackBack (0)
Apples To Apples
In this post, some have expressed skepticism about comparisons between marine hardware and space hardware. Fair enough (and amusing that such a minor item out of the post has consumed all of the discussion about it). Here's one that will be harder to argue with. XCOR Chief Engineer Dan DeLong has experience in both worlds, and offers this little tale: In the mid 1960s, the U.S. Navy decided to upgrade its capability to rescue crewmen from a stricken submarine. The McCann diving bell had been in service for over 30 years and had severe operational drawbacks. A new program to develop a submersible that would perform far better was started. The Navy contracted with Lockheed Missiles and Space, and the two Deep Submergence Rescue Vehicles were created. The first DSRV was built for $41 million . The two DSRVs performed well in trials (they have never been called to do their primary mission) and are still in service today.Posted by Rand Simberg at 08:45 AM | Comments (7) | TrackBack (0)
March 02, 2004
Georgetown Space Policy Panel Report More-than-occasional commenter Chuck Divine has a more extensive first-hand report from the panel discussion on space policy in Georgetown a few weeks ago. READ THE REST!...Posted by Rand Simberg at 09:33 PM | Comments (19) | TrackBack (0)
Going Group
Partly due to a paucity of time in which to post, and partly out of a desire to broaden the opinion bases here, Transterrestrial is becoming a group blog. I'll still be posting, but there should be more content here as a result. The first two victims that I've signed up are Allen Thomson and Andrew Case. Unfortunately, Dr. Case has a family emergency that's taking him out of internet range, so we may not hear from him for a week and a half or so, but in general keep an eye out for new talent here (better, in all cases, than your humble correspondent). [Update on Wednesday evening] A commenter asks if I can provide some background to the new posters. I could, but I think that they could do so much better than I, and I expect that they'll do so in their initial posts. Just keep sitting on the edge of your seats, folks... Posted by Rand Simberg at09:41 AM | Comments (4) | TrackBack (0)
March 01, 2004
So What About Tomorrow's Announcement? [Shrug] Unless they say that Marvin wants to negotiate before we go up there and kick his scrawny Martian butt for sabotaging all of our probes, I've little interest. I've been very busy (though I'll have a little more time now), but even if I were posting at full speed, space science just doesn't scratch my itch, and I hope that people don't come here in expectation of either excitement or profound thoughts on the subject. My interest is in getting earth life into space, not looking for non-earth life. If all they say manana is that there's water on Mars, that's not news. We've known it for years. If they say they've found amino acids, that's more interesting, but no more so to me than, say, the discovery of some new form of life on the ocean bottom. Posted by Rand Simberg at07:42 PM | Comments (23) | TrackBack (0)
February 29, 2004
OK, That's Close Enough I heard on the radio that he left "to avoid bloodshed." Funny, he didn't seem to mind all the bloodshed of the past few years of his presidency. I'll bet he could paint a barn with someone else's blood. One can't help but cynically sense that the only blood that he was concerned about being shed was his own. Posted by Rand Simberg at06:49 AM | Comments (5) | TrackBack (0)
February 27, 2004
The New Language Of Anti-Americanism Victor Davis Hanson has some words of wisdom for those who whine about "unilateralism" and "preemption." Posted by Rand Simberg at08:23 AM | Comments (9) | TrackBack (0)
Who's Best For Space?
The San Francisco Chronicle has some positions on space policy from the presidential candidates. Sen. John Edwards: "I am a strong supporter of our space program. It reflects the best of the American spirit of optimism, discovery and progress. A manned mission to Mars is in the American tradition of setting ambitious goals for exploring space, but we must be able to pay for the program." What does that mean? Sounds like he's saying it would be a nice thing to do if we can afford it, but he doesn't know whether we can, and it wouldn't necessarily be a priority of his to find a way to do it. And of course he focuses on the mission to Mars, with no hint of an understanding of broader issues or purposes. This isn't a statement that's going to gather any significant support from the space activist community (not that it's an important voting block). He's just trying to avoid taking an actual position. Sen. John Kerry: "Our civilian space program represents a great opportunity for scientific research. Sending a person to Mars is a great mission worthy of a great nation like America. Given the Bush budget deficit, it is imperative that we balance funding for a manned mission to Mars against critical domestic needs as well, such as education and health care." Again, hardly a forthright declaration of intent, and again, the focus is on sending someone to Mars. And again, no sophistication or nuance, or indication of an understanding of the issues. Also, it betrays either a fundamental ignorance of budgetary matters, or disingenuousness (you can guess where my money would be), because it implies that the budgets for space, and education and health care are somehow comparable, and that there is a scale on which we could place space on one side, and the social programs on the other, and it would be roughly balanced. The reality, of course, is that you could pay for a mission to Mars with a single month's expenditure on those other items, and get a lot of change. You could fund an invigorated space program with a tiny fraction of the education and health budgets, but if you took all the funding going into federal space activities and put it into education and health, it would hardly be noticed. Both Kerry's and Edwards' statements are empty motherhood, but Kerry's seems more cynical to me. Rep. Dennis Kucinich: "An International Space Station in Earth orbit is a far more practical launch platform than a base on the moon. So, if we as a nation decide to send manned missions to Mars, I would not support construction of a lunar base. In regard to space exploration, we are faced with an unprecedented national deficit and a war without end, both of which will force this nation to abandon many hopes, dreams and aspirations, including space exploration, if allowed to continue." I actually like Kucinich' position better. It seems much more honest. I don't agree with it, and he's technically wrong, but it looks like he's actually given the matter some thought, in the warped mindset in which he lives, and he actually has a position. It sounds as though he'd actually try to fund something (albeit at the expense of the Pentagon budget). Al Sharpton: No response. No surprise. No disappointment, either, except that he might have said something amusing. President Bush: No response." No need for one. He's on record as of January 14th what his space policy is. From a purely space policy standpoint, I think that George Bush is the best candidate. His policy's not perfect, but it's a vast improvement over that of Clinton, and either Kerry or Edwards would be likely to return to a more Clintonesque policy, with emphasis on jobs and international cooperation, and a lack of interest in actual accomplishments. To the degree that the president's policy is a good one, they can almost be counted upon to reverse it simply because it's his, and there's nothing in either of their stated positions here to indicate that their replacement would be an improvement in any way. Posted by Rand Simberg at06:24 AM | Comments (33) | TrackBack (0)
February 26, 2004
Gratuitous Violence? I have zero, no--make that negative--desire to see Mel Gibson's latest flick, for exactly the reasons that Andrew Sullivan (as devout a Catholic as it's possible for a gay man to be) describes. The center-piece of the movie is an absolutely disgusting and despicable piece of sadism that has no real basis in any of the Gospels. It shows a man being flayed alive - slowly, methodically and with increasing savagery. We first of all witness the use of sticks, then whips, then multiple whips with barbed glass or metal. We see flesh being torn out of a man's body. Just so that we can appreciate the pain, we see the whip first tear chunks out of a wooden table. Then we see pieces of human skin flying through the air. We see Jesus come back for more. We see blood spattering on the torturers' faces. We see muscled thugs exhausted from shredding every inch of this man's body. And then they turn him over and do it all again. It goes on for ever. And then we see his mother wiping up masses and masses of blood. It is an absolutely unforgivable, vile, disgusting scene. No human being could sruvive it. Yet for Gibson, it is the h'ors d'oeuvre for his porn movie. I respect the faith of those who do believe and accept the story of Christ--they are clearly, for the most part, sincere. But it's one that has never had any resonance to me--it simply makes no sense, and I am bemused by the bizarre notion that I had anything to do with an event which, if it happened at all, happened two millennia ago. Sorry, no, we didn't all kill him. I accept no responsibility whatsoever. I also have trouble getting my head around the notion that (as some have stated over at the Corner) this was "the greatest crime in history." Greater than the Holocaust? Greater than the Cultural Revolution? Greater than the deliberate starvation of the Ukrainians? Really? Only if one accepts the premise. (And no, please don't try to persuade me, or others, of the truth of the Gospels in my comments section--there will be no sale, and it just wastes my bandwidth and disk space--in fact, I will delete any preaching or witnessing--providing a forum for others to proselytize on subjects of little interest to me is not the purpose of my web site). It seems to me that Mr. Gibson has simply transferred his love of gory cinema to a purpose that he considers higher than money-making shoot'em ups. Perhaps if I were a believer, I might be willing to sit through such an exaggerated reenactment, but given my lack of belief about it, I see no redeeming value to the movie, at least for me, and Mr. Gibson will not be receiving any of my money for his little venture. [Update on Friday morning] Leon Wieseltier agrees with me, and much more eloquently (of course, he's actually seen the thing). He too, calls it a "sacred snuff film." It will be objected that I see only pious pornography in The Passion of the Christ because I am not a believer in the Christ. This is certainly so. I do not agree that Jesus is my savior or anybody else's. I confess that I smiled when the credits to The Passion of the Christ listed "stunts." So I am not at all the person for whom Gibson made this movie. But I do not see how a belief in Jesus strengthens the case for such a film. Quite the contrary. Belief, a theory of meaning, a philosophical convenience, is rarely far away from cruelty. Torture has always been attended by explanations that vindicate it, and justify it, and even hallow it. These explanations, which are really extenuations, have been articulated in religious and in secular terms. Their purpose is to redescribe an act of inhumanity so that it no longer offends, so that it comes to seem necessary, so that it edifies. My victim of torture is your martyr. While I'm willing to accept that a belief in Jesus strengthens the case for such a film (or at least I find the proposition no more baffling than a belief in Jesus itself), I can't imagine that it would have any influence in creating a belief in Jesus. This is a film for hard-core Christians, and it certainly won't hold any sway over people for whom there's not at least a seed of belief to begin with. Posted by Rand Simberg at07:33 AM | Comments (44) | TrackBack (2)
February 25, 2004
Marching Morons Last fall, some clueless Arizona legislators were contemplating handing over the state cryonics industry to the funeral industry. The notion was roundly and appropriately panned, but unfortunately, it doesn't seem to have gone away. They're still at it. If you're an Arizona resident, and interested in extending your life (or just slapping down legislative stupidity), use the tips at this site and contact your state representative. [Update on Thursday morning] Looks like most AZ legislators have more sense than Mr. Stump. Thanks to vigorous action on the part of Alcor, this bill is going nowhere. [Update on Friday] Ron Bailey has further commentary. Endquote and good point: Far from protection for frozen heads, this looks like just another attempt to use government to restrict competition—because, in a devoutly-to-be-wished world where cryonics dreams come true, the undertakers, and their regulators, will be out of business. And good riddance.Posted by Rand Simberg at 10:25 PM | Comments (1) | TrackBack (0)
Safe Enough?
Well, I was wrong. A year ago, right after the loss of the Space Shuttle Columbia, I predicted that the standdown from the Columbia disaster wouldn't be anywhere near as long as the one after the loss of the Challenger (over two years), but it now looks as though it may in fact approach it. My reasons for that prediction were two: First, that the shuttle was needed to support the continued construction and maintenance of the space station (a circumstance that didn't hold in the late 1980s). Second, I didn't think that the investigation would reveal as much of a problem this time as when Challenger was lost, in terms of poor NASA judgement. But apparently, in the wake of the harsh criticism of the Gehman Commission, NASA has become ultraconservative in Shuttle operations. The unwillingness to risk a Hubble maintenance mission is one symptom of this. The recent announcement that the first post-Columbia flight will be delayed until at least a year from now is another. I didn't agree with the Hubble decision (and continue to disagree), and I think that NASA is being too cautious now in delaying return to flight. Of course, I thought they were after Challenger as well--they could have safely flown a month later, as long as they did it in reasonably warm weather that wouldn't freeze O-rings, and much of the redesign of the Solid Rocket Booster joints was overkill, or at least it wasn't necessary to wait until it was complete to start flying again. Is the Shuttle as safe to fly as it can possibly be right now? No, but that's a foolish standard. While "Safety First" has a nice ring to it, there has to be a rational balance between safety and effectiveness. After all, the safest flight of a Shuttle (or for that matter, any vehicle) is the one that doesn't occur at all (effectively the course taken over the past year, and apparently the next as well). We are spending almost as much on the Shuttle when it doesn't fly as we would if it were--NASA can't simply put the processing staff in cold storage until they decide to fly again, and if they lay them off, there's a good chance that they won't be available when they decide to return to flight, so we're spending the money and getting very little value for it. I've long argued that, despite the national keening and wailing when astronauts die, the real asset at risk in a Shuttle launch is the orbiter itself, of which we now have only three left, and each of which would cost many years and several billion dollars to replace, given that the tooling needed to build them, and many of the subcontractors who contributed to their construction no longer exist. We simply couldn't afford to risk losing another one, and have any hope of maintaining a viable fleet into the future. But that argument went away on January 14th, when the president announced his new space policy. In fact, as September 11, 2001 was a watershed date in our foreign policy, January 14th, 2004 was, or at least should be seen as, a similar demarcation in national space policy. On that date, among other things, it became formal policy of the United States that we would no longer rely on the Space Shuttle into the indefinite future. That policy implicitly converted the Shuttle fleet from a precious and irreplaceable asset to be protected at all costs, to a depreciating one, from which as much value should be extracted as possible before it is retired in a few years. The Gehman Commission report came out before January 14, and while it requested a new space policy vision, it didn't necessarily anticipate it. While it recommended augmenting Shuttle with a new manned launch system, it didn't necessarily recommend eliminating the Shuttle quite as quickly, and if it had, the recommendations might have been a little different. To the degree that NASA policy remains driven by the CAIB recommendations, it would be useful to have a reconvening of the commission and revisit them to determine if the president's new policy might modify them. Under the new policy, there will be no more than another couple dozen flights or so of the fleet. It's unlikely that what happened to Columbia will happen to another vehicle, because even if the foam problem isn't fixed, the chances of a repeat over that number of missions is very low. After all, this was the first time it happened in over a hundred. And even if there is another event, we could probably still complete the ISS with the remaining fleet of two, though it might delay it another year or so. In addition, the president's policy implies that completion of the ISS is no longer an urgent national goal (most Beltway insiders know that the main reason it wasn't cancelled was to avoid upsetting the international partners--not because it's in any way essential to the new goals). Under those circumstances, we really should ask ourselves if the costs of modifying the Shuttle system for improved safety, and the opportunity costs of not flying while continuing to pay the salaries of the Shuttle program personnel, are really worth the avoided (low) risk of not losing another orbiter and crew. A rational assessment might indicate that the answer is no, but then, one can't always expect rational assessments to prevail in programs so dominated by politics as our space program remains, and I suspect that decisions will continue to be made on the basis of a mindset that's "soooo January 13th." Posted by Rand Simberg at12:48 PM | Comments (21) | TrackBack (1)
Defending The Planet
Leonard David continues to report from this week's planetary defense conference in Garden Grove, CA. The consensus? We need to get more serious about this threat. NASA now supports -- in collaboration with the United States Air Force -- the Spaceguard Survey and its goal of discovering and tracking 90 percent of the Near Earth Asteroids (NEAs) with a diameter greater than about one-half mile (1 kilometer) by 2008. If one of these big bruisers were to strike our planet, it would spark catastrophic global effects that would include severe regional devastation and global climate change. This needs to be more closely coordinated with the president's new space policy, both programmatically and politically. Posted by Rand Simberg at11:49 AM | Comments (9) | TrackBack (1)
February 24, 2004
Planet Busters There's an interesting conference this week just down the street from where I'm working. Unfortunately, I'm too busy working to attend, but it's nice to see people taking this threat more seriously. Posted by Rand Simberg at07:17 AM | Comments (1) | TrackBack (0)
February 23, 2004
Not About Space I've often said that Apollo wasn't about space, and that was one of the reasons that those who hope to resurrect the "space program" on an Apollo model are doomed to failure. The implication, of course, is that space activities that "aren't about space" are a bad thing. My old friend (old in the sense that I've known him a long time, not that either he or I are old...) Jim Muncy has a different opinion: Space exploration is not merely about the wonders of science and technology, although it produces countless discoveries and innovations. It is not merely about stunning images and daring adventures, although it has those aplenty. And to the disbelief of so many space professionals and aficionados alike, it is not even really about outer space. RTWT [via Mark Whittington] Posted by Rand Simberg at10:51 PM | Comments (9) | TrackBack (0)
Failed Dreams
Dwayne Day has the conclusion to his piece at The Space Review on the history of the SEI program. A key point, that I've often made, and one that the Easterbrooks and other spewers of costing nonsense should understand: One of the major problems facing NASA was a cultural one, an inability to think of new human spaceflight projects in terms other than the Apollo paradigm. During Apollo, NASA had gotten a huge amount of money and a great deal of autonomy and many at the agency still thought they would conduct SEI in the same manner. They therefore felt no pressure to keep costs under control.Posted by Rand Simberg at 12:56 PM | Comments (10) | TrackBack (0)
An Empty Lap
When I first saw her, she was small enough to hold in my hand. My lover of the past seven years had just moved out, and taken custody of the cat (only fair, since it was originally hers). In sudden need of feline companionship (generally easier and faster to replace than the feminine variety--at least a satisfactory replacement), I responded to an ad on the bulletin board in the local grocery in El Segundo, and went to a house a few blocks from mine that was dispensing kittens from a recent litter. They were standard-issue tabbies, though a claim was made that they had a Siamese grandmother. There were four of them, playing with each other. That is, three of them were playing, and one was standing back, more aloof. It was a grayish color, with just a hint of brown stripes. It was a little smaller than the others, and looked to be the runt. I reached over and scratched between its outsized ears. It didn't seem afraid. "Her name is Francesca," one of the girls of the household offered helpfully. I opined that it was a pretty big moniker for such a little cat. I picked it up to inspect the nether regions, in order to verify the gender, and allow it to be henceforth described by a slightly more specific pronoun. After the inspection, she (as it indeed turned out to be) curled up in my hand, and promptly fell asleep. I realized that my choice was to either wake her up, or take her with me. She seemed to have adopted me, and it was the beginning of a long relationship in which she would, whenever possible, seek (and generally find, at least for a while) slothful slumber on various temporarily horizontal parts of my body. I think that she left her mother too soon--she wasn't properly weaned (perhaps partly because she was the runt of the litter, and could never get enough). For years after I got her, she would suck my finger with gusto if I offered it to her. It also took her a while to learn to, in Garrison Keillor's immortal words, work up the courage to do what needs to be done. When I first got her home, Stella (as I subsequently renamed her) hid under various articles of furniture for the first couple days. I gradually coaxed her out with bowls of food and milk. At first, she wouldn't go outside. Gradually, she started to adventure out the door, but she would only go as far as the extent of the shade of the house, stopping at the terminator drawn by the sun. She was like a little groundhog, fearing her own shadow. But eventually, she worked up the grit and gumption to explore the whole yard, and after a few weeks, she would come in only for food and to sleep on me, two passions in which she indulged herself almost to the end of her days. It turned out that the aloofness toward her siblings at our first meeting was not out of character--Stella hated cats with a fierce passion (again, perhaps a symptom of having to fight for her place at the dairy, and often losing). I'm not sure what she thought she was. Accordingly, when Patricia brought Jessica into the house a few years later, she didn't take well to the interloper, growling at her whenever in her presence (other than at dinner time, when she was too busy stuffing her jowls to notice the other cat next door). Taking her away from her mother early didn't seem to have damaged her other natural instincts--she was a great ratter, one time cleaning out the garage from an infestation. But she'd been slowing down in recent years, as she approached her fifteenth birthday. I dropped her off at the vet on Thursday evening for a follow-up visit from her hospital stay last week. She'd been eating all right for the past couple days, but I didn't get a chance to feed her before I took her in, because I had been working late and had to get her there before the office closed. I boarded her there for the weekend because I was going away, and there was no one else who could get the pills into her twice daily. I planned to pick her up on Monday morning before work. On Friday, I got a call from the vet. She told me that her blood count was back down as low as it was when I first brought her in the previous week, and that she was extremely weak again, with a lowered temperature. She was afraid that there was more going on than just the blood parasite that had been diagnosed, and for which she was being treated. She thought that without another transfusion, she would not last long. Unfortunately, even with another transfusion, the prognosis was poor, and it would be very expensive, because this time she would have to go to an emergency clinic to have the blood typed, and a battery of tests to determine what the problem was. She feared that it was perhaps a previously undiagnosed cancer. The choices were to spend thousands of dollars to keep her alive a while longer, or to see if she could fight her way back again, and hope for the best. She didn't seem to be suffering, other than being very weak, so there was no consideration of euthanizing her. I was torn because I was two thousand miles away, and didn't want her to die alone, in a strange place, but I was helpless, short of spending a lot of money that I didn't have, probably in futility. We decided to give her one more chance to fight her way through, as she had the previous weekend, but with little hope. On Saturday, the doctor called to tell me that the fierce little flame had finally flickered out in the night. No more clawing furniture, or catching rats, or sitting on laps, unless she's gone to a place where all those feline recreations are available in abundance, and perpetuity. Jessica now has no one to annoy by batting her tail, or leaping from heights. She'll be cremated, and I'll scatter the ashes in the yard in which she spent so many contented hours playing and sunning.
12:47 PM | Comments (29) | TrackBack (7) |
Monthly Archives Recent posts |